or to join or start a new Discussion

16 Comments
Article Rating 1 Star

Question.

If Arsene Wenger was in charge of Spurs this season, and Harry Redknapp in charge of Arsenal, what sort of seasons would both clubs be having now with the same players at their disposal? Better or worse?

Admins, can you put this on the Arsenal board too?

posted on 19/2/12

It's impossible to answer but Harry has really improved our squad over the last couple of years .....You have to say that things have gone downhill at Arsenal , I don't mean that nastily but even the most ardent goooner would struggle to deny that

Sorry I still have no idea

posted on 19/2/12

I don't know how Wenger would have fared if he suddenly had taken charge of Tottenham because I have no idea if he would have elected to play the kind of football that he used to when he first came to us, or if he'd have tried to implement the same rigid gameplan he has us using now.

But I do think Redknapp would have us faring alot better than we are.

posted on 19/2/12

Wenger would probably have Spurs in the top PL top 4.
But where they are now, who knows.


"But I do think Redknapp would have us faring alot better than we are."

Arry does seem to give his players the necessary s to raise their spirits. That is something that Wenger does not appear to do.

posted on 19/2/12

You have taken a fair bit of cash in and not spent too much ......Wenger has always said that there was money available if he wanted it , do you think that's true ???? or is he trying to put a united front up ???

TBH a lot of the credit for our improvement has to go down to Levy so the other factor you have to take into account in your original post is which board as well ...............

posted on 19/2/12

AuHasardBendtner

BTW you can place the same article on two sites by typing in the name of your other team in one of the small rectangles on the create page

posted on 19/2/12

Harry would have arshavin playing great stuff I reckon

posted on 19/2/12

Same board. It's very hard to say whose responsible for our need to make a profit or if they're all in cahoots together or what. As a gunner, that's more frustrating than seeing Walcott in the starting line-up. But anyway, the boards are kinda irrelevant as I'm just talking about the current set of players both teams have. Over a longer timeframe the board question would become very relevant.

Also, I'm not allowed multi-board my articles. Must have abused the function in the past.

posted on 19/2/12

I know this is "off topic" but I want to know what you guys think:
Was the offside rule applied correctly in today's game against Stevenage?
Always though the player involved had to have some intention of playing the ball??

posted on 20/2/12

Hypothetically...

There's no way Harry would put up with some of the characters in the Arsenal squad - that's not a dig just my honest opinion. While some fans are critical of Harry playing favourites with players (me included) this is a trait he shares with SAF. Those that don't toe the line get shipped out, harsh but fair.

In short I reckon Wenger would do ok with the current Spurs squad but Harry would struggle to make a team out of your lot.

posted on 20/2/12

I know this is "off topic" but I want to know what you guys think:
Was the offside rule applied correctly in today's game against Stevenage
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Yes it was perfectly applied

Sign in if you want to comment
RATE THIS ARTICLE
Rate Breakdown
5
0 Votes
4
0 Votes
3
0 Votes
2
0 Votes
1
0 Votes

Average Rating: 1 from 1 vote

ARTICLE STATS
Day
Article RankingNot Ranked
Article ViewsNot Available
Average Time(mins)Not Available
Total Time(mins)Not Available
Month
Article RankingNot Ranked
Article ViewsNot Available
Average Time(mins)Not Available
Total Time(mins)Not Available